Jump to content

Wiki Research Ideas/Review model

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki

Which peer review model - for a journal on Wikis?

[edit]

open peer review

[edit]
pro
[edit]
contra
[edit]
undecided/ weighing
[edit]

combining open and closed

[edit]

e.g.: ACP: 8 weeks of post publication public discussion combined with closed peer review

pro
[edit]
contra
[edit]
undecided/ weighing
[edit]

double-blind peer review

[edit]
pro
[edit]
contra
[edit]
undecided/ weighing
[edit]

single-blind peer review

[edit]
pro
[edit]
contra
[edit]
undecided/ weighing
[edit]