User talk:LeoRomero/feedbackform

The idea that creating more rules improves anything is a misconception. Less is more!
The words "no more than three lines" are meaningless. 3 lines on an iPhone's screen are only a handful of words, but on my beamer I can write a novel in three lines.
Restricting the amount of lines/sentences/words is a bad idea. You can write something like "Participants are encouraged to limit themselves to ?? sentences/words" or "Please keep your proposal as short as possible".
Explicitly asking people to be civil/kind is quite impolite. Do you assume that they won't be if you don't ask them to? Criticizing a bad idea someone had isn't unkind, you are helping them improve their idea, and honest feedback is far kinder than pretending their ideas are good when they are actually bad.
The "Submit your suggestion" form should have a prefilled list of endorsements where people can simply add their signature.

Title of proposal

This is the description of the proposal. There is no strict limit but people are encouraged to keep it as short as possible

Please add your opinion and signature to this list.
Oppose terrible idea because potatoes cannot fly. Critic1 (talk) 23:08, 14 November 2015 (UTC)
Support great idea because potatoes are able to hover. Supporter1 (talk) 23:08, 14 November 2015 (UTC)