Jump to content

User talk:Klip game

Add topic
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Latest comment: 17 years ago by Klip game in topic Russian Revolution

My contributions to List of articles every Wikipedia should have:

To rename section "Religion" into "World view"

[edit]

I am sorry for bad English. IMHO section "Religion" need to rename into "World view". "Atheism" is very strange to placed in "Religion" section. If to speak about worldview, their list is necessary. I offer the following list:

  1. World view
  2. Worldview philosophies
    1. Atheism
    2. Materialism
    3. Monotheism
    4. Polytheism
    5. Fundamentalism

Word "Festival" in English language has religious interpretation probably. But in Russian and Ukrainian "Festival" does not associate in any way with religion. IMHO It is not necessary to include such individual interpretation for all languages and delete from this section. --Klip game 09:37, 25 January 2007 (UTC)Reply

This is a very valid suggestion. However, I am compelled to remove six of your entries since they pushed the number of articles to 1006 (1007 actually, but someone was kind enough to remove en:Compact disc since then). Hence the list is six entries too long. I am very adamant about keeping the list at exactly 1000 entries, as it has a certain inbuilt tendency to grow out of every proportion and hence becoming useless for smaller wikipedias (for which it is intended) when the mere task of translating it becomes monumental (leaving aside the task of creating articles for all these entries). I therefore suggest that you remove six entries that you think are less important than the ones you added to round the list back to 1000 entries or (better) suggest deletions here that they may be discussed. --Akigka 15:51, 25 January 2007 (UTC)Reply
I have used your kind sanction and has removed some words that I think are less important than my added:
  • World view and religion
    1. Astrology (It is a pseudo-science, instead of world view or religion)
    2. Festival (I have proved above)
    3. Worldview (I have caused it, I shall kill it :)
  • Recreation
    1. Judo (This one of Martial arts. Let other Martial arts do not take offence.)
    2. Party (I do not think, that the Party is valid so is important.)
  • War and military
    1. Infantry (If to save Infantry, then is necessary artillery, military aircraft...)
  • Architecture and civil engineering
    1. Nail (Why do you need Nail, if you dont have hammer :)
  • Technology
    1. Coinage (Let manufacture of coins will be in a secret. If someone will begin it to make then the state does not like.)
I have removed more than it is necessary that there was a reserve :) --Klip game 10:51, 26 January 2007 (UTC)Reply
I agree with removing. --Igrek 11:18, 26 January 2007 (UTC)Reply

Russian Revolution

[edit]

I have decided to offer one more important theme: History/Modern/Russian Revolution of 1917. I understand debatableness it, but this event in many respects has predetermined a history 20 centuries. I hope what is it mine last editing of the list. --Klip game 11:49, 26 January 2007 (UTC)Reply