User talk:Fadli Idris
Add topicLatest comment: 13 years ago by WhisperToMe in topic Reply
Selamat Datang ke Meta!
[edit]
Halo Fadli Idris!, dan Selamat Datang di Wikimedia Meta-Wiki! Situs web ini berperan sebagai tempat koordinasi dan diskusi mengenai seluruh proyek-proyek Wikimedia. Mungkin akan bermanfaat bagi Anda untuk membaca halaman kebijakan kami. Jika Anda tertarik untuk melakukan penerjemahan, kunjungi Meta:Babylon. Anda juga dapat meninggalkan pesan di Meta:Babel atau Wikimedia Forum (bacalah petunjuk di bagian atas halaman tersebut sebelum meninggalkan pesan di sana). Selamat menyunting! — Mikhailov Kusserow (talk) 11:03, 16 June 2009 (UTC)
Reply
[edit]Hi! I don't think you are reading this anymore, but I thought I would comment:
- "Wikipedia is not a project with a neutral point of view, wikipedia allow images deemed insulting a religion."
- If Wikipedia had presented the images as if they were the truth, then yes. But Wikipedia is simply stating these images exist, showing what they look like so people can decide "are they insulting?" - and describing the history and makings of these images. The English Wikipedia has many images offensive to many groups (Nazi images, anti-Christian imagery, sexual images, etc). The English Wikipedia isn't judging "these images are right" - But in order to teach people about the images, we believe that we have to display them.
- "Many cases resolved by way of voting to reach consensus to the exclusion of minority opinions. Therefore, I stopped to contribute in wikipedia to a change in policy." - Well, minority opinions are given due consideration. On the English Wikipedia we decided to reject the minority rationale. This doesn't mean that there was no fairness given.
- As stated by many others, Aceh Wikipedia can prevent the display of the images on its own page.
- I think the best way to handle it is for you to ask Muslim Wikipedians who share your beliefs to follow the instructions at en:Talk:Muhammad/FAQ and block their own accounts from seeing those images
WhisperToMe 01:24, 14 February 2011 (UTC)
- For Meta, I made User:WhisperToMe/Userboxes/NoMo WhisperToMe 05:48, 17 February 2011 (UTC)