User:Slowking4/Gender Gap & civility
Appearance
"decline will continue based on organizational culture, until an investment is made to shift the culture."
- Gender gap strategy 2013: Audiences/Allies/Stakeholders
- Gender gap strategy
- In the Gender Gap strategy there was a call for Allies training.
Sitrep
[edit]- Why Trolls Start Flame Wars: Swearing and Name-Calling Shut Down the Ability to Think and Focus [2]
- Survey: Online trolls are 'everyday sadists' [3]
- Men Play a Key Role in Helping Women in Tech [4]
- So this is happening. Concerned Feminists (@concernedfems) Ally Bingo
- http://www.catehuston.com/blog/2014/10/09/a-small-internet-kerfuffle/
- The Unsafety Net: How Social Media Turned Against Women
- What is turning so many young men into internet trolls?
- http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Michael_Schwern_arrest
- http://www.katelosse.tv/latest/2014/9/12/magical-futures
Prevailing attitudes
[edit]- How to Spot – and Defeat – Disruption on the Internet [5]
- Start a partisan divide-and-conquer fight
- Pretend it’s hopeless because we’ll be squashed if we try.
- Demand complete, fool-proof and guaranteed solutions
- Suggest extreme, over-the-top, counter-productive solutions
- Pretend that alternative media are untrustworthy
- Coordinate with a couple of others to “shout down”
- Use an army of sock puppets.
- Censor social media
- “unforeseeable” and that “no could have known”
- “conspiracy theory”.
- Become incredulous and indignant
- Use a straw man.
- Hit and Run
- Question motives
- Associate opponent charges with old news
- while, organizing and ally building is less satisfying than fighting, i would suggest that we want to shape the conflict on terrain of our choosing. battle ground, and ANI, and Arbcom is the terrain of the disruptors.
- united we stand
- the power of the wiki is never hopeless
- produce small incremental solutions that can be iterated
- reinforce success & fail faster
- trust but verify
- Coordinate to insist upon civility
- Use an army of sock puppets.
- use social media to organize
- foresee the predictable behaviors
- counter conspiracy with cabal
- Become measured and calm
- Use real man examples.
- stand and deliver
- ignore motives, question actions and results
- learn old news as history, pattern of behavior
Philosophy
[edit]- Geek Feminism Wiki Allies workshop
- Men on a mission, Harvard Business School
- https://www.seas.harvard.edu/news/2014/02/closing-gender-gap-in-computer-science
- Gender_gap_task_force#A_multipronged_strategy
- Science Explains Why the Silent Treatment Works
- 5 Weird Habits That Make People Successful And Awesome
Action plan
[edit]- organize
- find allies Allies training
- label bad behavior
- do good work
- route around obstructions
- We want to create circles of civility, while we cannot depend on the WMF to maintain a "no asshole zone", we can build a civility zone among ourselves. we can build tactics to respond to incivility.
- by creating circles that are civilly supporting, they can then change the larger community by building a new consensus; build the circle, expand the circle, maintain the circle
- we can train Ambassadors that will mentor newbies, and respond on their behalf, when incivility occurs.
- we can train allies to intervene on behalf of the hounded, negative feedback to bad behavior, and validate, and reinforce good behavior.