User:Kleuske/Huang Xianfan
On Sunday August 15th user ErikvanB nominated two pages, nl:Huang Xianfan and nl:Zhuangstudie for deletion, citing poor use of language and the sheer wikipedia precence. Simular articles exist on (according to the nominator) 160 wiki's. Contributors to these pages are usually quite singleminded and contrubute to (virtually) nothing else. As evidence for his claim, ErikvanB provided the following excerpt of his findings
The same user, also alerted me to a few interesting remarks, zuch as user Xiyang being blocked for sockpuppetry and the discussion on Huang Xianfan, where people wondered how Huang Xianfan appears on more wikipedia projects than Mao Zedong. Which is remarkable, to say the least. The discussion of whether or not these are automatic translations also yields some interesting information:
- [1] Bulgarians are asking questions and think the language of the article is indicative of a machine translation
- [2] In japan, the language is called funny japanese.
- [3] Latvians also have these doubts.
Anonymous contributions
[edit]Given the subject matter, it is not unexpected that a majority of anonymous contributors comes from china. What is a bit weird, and telling, is that all of them come from two networks: Hurricane Electric, Inc. and CHINANET Guangxi. If this person were as wellknown as the spread of the articles on wikipedia suggests, i would expect to see more providers hosting anonymous contributors. Instead, there's only 2.
Data
[edit]These are the finding as provided by nl:Gebruiker:ErikvanB.
| Article | Wiki | Created | Created by | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| af:Huang Xianfan | af | june 2009 | Professor | |
| ak:Huang Xianfan | ak | 2010 | Beringer | |
| ang:Huang Siānfan | ang | july 2009 | Volkker | |
| bar:Huang Xianfan | bar | february 2010 | Agneichs | |
| bcl:Huang Xianfan | bcl | june 2009 | Klindondon | |
| ca:Huang Xianfan | ca | may 2009 | Histò | |
| cdo:Uòng Hiêng-huàng | cdo | 2009 | Cháung-gióng-ciā | |
| da:Huang Xianfan | da | may 2009 | Prette | |
| de:Huang Xianfan | de | may 2009 | Werke max | |
| en:Huang Xianfan | en | april 2009 | Xiyang | blocked for use of sockpuppets |
| es:Huang Xianfan | es | may 2009 | Clous | |
| fi:Huang Xianfan | fi | may 2009 | Käyttä | |
| fr:Huang Xianfan | fr | april 2009 | Xiyang | |
| fy:Huang Xianfan | fy | june 2009 | Nijeste | |
| it:Huang Xianfan | it | april 2009 | Parper | |
| la:Huang Xianfan | la | mei 2009 | Christian | la |
| li:Huang Xianfan | li | juni 2009 | Scherma | |
| mt:Huang Xianfan | mt | may 2009 | Kotbas | |
| w:nl:Huang Xianfan | nl | 12 may 2009 | Gekoze | |
| pl:Huang Xianfan | pl | april 2009 | Shiqing | |
| pt:Huang Xianfan | pt | may 2009 | Kerlaker | |
| ru:Хуан Сяньфань | ru | may 2009 | 小桥人家 | |
| sv:Huang Xianfan | sv | may 2009 | Giammoin |
Contributors
[edit]The following is a breakdown of contributions by user. Users who have contributed to only one project were omitted, as were (most of the) bots, at least, those i could confirm were actual bots. The table was composed by a tool called Droopy, which i constructed for the occasion...
Usernames in red denote users who's only contributions (worldwide) are to the article in question or related matters uzhc as creating categories to hold the article, inserting it into list of anthropologists, etc. The green usernames denote those that were detected, but contribute to a wide range of subjects.
| User | Edits (total) | Projects | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spamiut | 9 | da id ms pt ro vi zh | |
| Busisi | 13 | bm en ga yo zh | blocked for sockpuppetry. See en:Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Qiwengong/Archive |
| Aŭtomadd | 8 | eo nov zh | |
| Võitnimä | 5 | fiu-vro zh | |
| Guaka | 2 | bm en | |
| Uceţi | 13 | mt ro zh | |
| 125.73.95.90 | 2 | en zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 124.226.117.54 | 21 | CHINANET Guangxi | |
| 124.226.119.114 | 4 | ca fi pt zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Loveless | 71 | als an ang ar az be be-x-old bi ca ceb co da de el eo es et eu fr fy gl he hr ia id ja jbo ko ku kw la lb lt mk ms nds pl ps ro ru scn sh sk sl sq su th tr uk uz vi vo wa zh-yue | interwiki fixer. |
| 65.49.2.170 | 14 | bi bs cbk-zam dsb eo ext fo ht kab mi tw | Hurricane Electric, Inc. |
| Agneichs | 2 | bar tw | |
| 124.226.113.229 | 21 | de en es fi fr gan id it ja ko la nl pl pt ru simple vi wuu zh zh-yue | |
| Phishn | 8 | gl hr sl zh | |
| Klindondon | 6 | bcl pam zh | |
| 黄英雄 | 3 | jbo zh | |
| 偶做前堂客 | 45 | ja zh zh-classical | |
| Φουσοι | 3 | en es zh | |
| 韦一民 | 11 | en za zh | |
| Parper | 32 | en fr gan it pl wuu zh zh-yue | |
| 124.226.114.13 | 3 | es fi it | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Sčia | 8 | lt lv zh | |
| Томатич | 36 | ar bg ca da de en es fi fr gan id it ja ko la ms mt nl pl pt ro ru simple sr sv tr uk vi wuu za zh zh-yue | |
| Käyttä | 11 | fi zh | |
| Čállisa | 10 | is se | |
| 116.1.13.45 | 4 | ja zh | CHINANET Guangxi, Likely, but no clear cut case. |
| KNOLGOOGLE | 4 | tw zh | |
| РобоСтася | 2 | ru uk | |
| 125.73.53.163 | 6 | ja zh-classical | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 124.226.114.4 | 15 | en es it ja ko la ru simple vi zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Qiwengong | 85 | en ja zh zh-classical | blocked for sockpuppetry. Uploaded images used. |
| Jakferwold | 4 | en nrm | blocked for sockpuppetry. |
| Kongfuzi | 17 | bi co en tw | |
| 124.226.114.218 | 3 | ja zh zh-classical | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Mercy | 3 | ch tw | |
| Силам | 5 | uk zh | |
| Purbo T | 13 | ast bat-smg br bs fiu-vro fy gl ksh ms sq sr tl zh-yue | |
| 222.84.159.145 | 2 | en fr | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Apjev | 3 | sq zh | |
| Huangwenkuei | 102 | af bcl be be-x-old bg cbk-zam ceb ch cv eo es et eu fa fi fiu-vro fr fy gan gd gl he hr hsb id ilo io is it ja ko ksh ku la lb li lt lv mk ms mt nds nds-nl nl oc pam pl ps pt qu ro ru scn sco se sh simple sk sl sq sr stq sv sw tl tr uk vi wa war wuu za zh zh-yue | |
| 124.226.117.21 | 3 | ja pl | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Másinzión | 11 | an az bat-smg zh | |
| 116.1.18.127 | 3 | fr za | CHINANET Guangxi |
| MacTire02 | 3 | ga gv | |
| Eastfrisian | 6 | de en nds nl | |
| Superzerocool | 4 | ceb de fiu-vro lad | |
| EVula | 17 | de en fr gan it ja ko pl simple wuu zh zh-yue | |
| Cooplaig | 3 | gv zh | |
| 124.226.123.157 | 7 | en ja pl | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Ptbotgourou | 9 | fiu-vro fr gan ko pl vi wuu za zh-yue | Bot? |
| Slb nsk | 3 | en ru | |
| Wóaderdets | 4 | dsb el jv | Mainly occupied by creation of categories. |
| Nijeste | 7 | fy mi zh | |
| Kebaikan | 7 | id ilo | |
| Werke max | 46 | de en es fr gan gn it ja pt ru simple vi wuu za zh zh-yue | |
| बीजिंग | 10 | bn mr sa | |
| Nýgftr | 5 | fo frp | |
| Jäjeaa | 4 | ksh zh | |
| Volkker | 27 | ang fr ht tw zh | |
| Henlebury | 53 | en es fi fr gan id it ja ko ms nl pl pt ru simple sv uk vi wuu za zh zh-yue | |
| Biŋhai | 5 | en za | |
| Zhuangzhuang | 48 | ar en es fi fr gan id it ja ko la ms nl pl ru simple vi wuu za zh zh-yue | |
| 124.226.116.51 | 3 | nds zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 本是后山人 | 11 | zh zh-classical | |
| Aizvē | 10 | bg ca cs et lv | |
| Michaello | 35 | ar bg ca cs da de en es et fi fr id it ja ko la lv ms mt nl pl pt ro ru simple sr sv tr uk vi wuu za zh zh-yue | Benign (interwiki fixer) |
| 116.1.15.8 | 4 | bg nl | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Abını | 6 | az zh | |
| 65.49.2.158 | 20 | Hurricane Electric, Inc. | |
| Asbós | 3 | oc zh | |
| Knol2010 | 4 | en zh | |
| 116.1.14.249 | 3 | ja zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 116.1.16.60 | 9 | en fr gan wuu zh-yue | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Smartmause | 11 | el en gan he hi ja mn th yi za zh-yue | |
| Red Winged Duck | 3 | be-x-old en | |
| Méifo | 5 | lb li | |
| Kahuroa | 7 | en mi | |
| Пдтавьь | 15 | bcl be bs os zh | |
| Kokobe | 6 | eu ja zh | |
| 65.49.2.15 | 2 | bi tw | Hurricane Electric, Inc. |
| 124.226.112.166 | 5 | de en es fr la | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Awsxz | 6 | als zh | |
| Zhxy 519 | 15 | en zh | |
| 124.226.118.196 | 2 | co zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 116.1.14.184 | 3 | es zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 124.226.125.205 | 2 | en es | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Здік | 7 | kk so | |
| Aenutse | 4 | stq zh | |
| Gekoze | 11 | en nl zh zh-yue | |
| 125.73.92.9 | 3 | hr zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 124.226.118.128 | 5 | en fr ja pl zh | CHINANET Guangxi |
| 125.73.93.227 | 5 | de en ja la | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Ašćik | 5 | hsb zh | |
| D'arc'ho | 5 | br zh | |
| Glasoaa | 3 | hr zh | |
| Nineshare | 3 | blocked for sockpuppetry | |
| Wutsje | 2 | af hsb | |
| 124.226.114.70 | 2 | en ja | CHINANET Guangxi |
| Stoigniew | 79 | be be-x-old bi ca cv da de es fi ht id it kk la mn ms mt nl os pl pms pt ro simple sr tg tw uk wa | |
| 李国威 | 9 | zh zh-classical | |
| Skyfiler | 20 | ast az be en ja zh | |
| Kerlaker | 14 | ca mt pt zh | |
| Andres | 4 | en et | |
| Icesea | 9 | bi co ilo ksh mi nds-nl se vo yo | |
| Xiyang | 76 | de en fr gan it ja mt nl pl ru wuu zh-yue | Notability discussion on fr, blocked for sockpuppetry |
| Alaniaris | 3 | el en | |
| Tailert | 4 | sco zh | |
| Пољпод | 8 | sr uk zh | |
| Višin | 3 | bs zh |