User:Galahad/criteria
Here is a list of criteria that I consider when voting on nominations on Meta-Wiki. I recognize that there may be instances where I am a bit more stringent, and in other cases, I might decide to deviate from these criteria.
To get my support for their request, the candidate needs to meet the five general points as well as the additional criteria specific to their request.
General points
[edit]| Things that will influence me to oppose. | Things that will influence me to vote neutral, or help me oppose/support. | Things that will influence me to support. |
|---|---|---|
| The candidate has less than 5000 global edits | The candidate has 10000 global edits | The candidate has 20000+ global edits |
| The candidate currently has an active justified block on any Wikimedia project. | N/A | The candidate has a clean record with no justified active blocks |
| The candidate's most recent nomination occurred less than three months ago. | N/A | The candidate's most recent nomination occurred either three months ago, in the event it was rejected, or six months ago if it was approved. |
| The candidate seeks clarification regarding the reasons behind negative or neutral comments and occasionally reaches out to those who made such remarks in contexts outside of Wikimedia projects. | The candidate engages with all opposing or neutral comments even when it may not be necessary. | The candidate prefers not to request explanations for negative or neutral comments, unless it is necessary for them to answer. |
| The user tends to leave negative comments that may come across as quite harsh, potentially raising concerns about the assumption of good faith. | The candidate expresses their opinion in a negative light, yet shows the capacity to reconsider their judgment, independent of any changes made to their comment. | The candidate is open to asking questions and genuinely seeks to understand others before forming any negative judgments. They are also able to extend the benefit of the doubt to those they trust, despite their limited experience. |
Additional criteria
[edit]| Permiso | Things that will influence me to support. | Things that will influence me to vote neutral, or help me oppose/support. | Things that will influence me to oppose. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stewards' confirmations | Active steward for at least six months | N/A | Non-active steward |
| Steward | Active global sysop for at least six months | N/A | The candidate is not a Global Sysop |
| Global Sysop |
|
N/A | The candidate is not a sysop or global rollbacker |
| Global Rollbacker | Sysop on a content project for a minimum of two years | N/A | The candidate is not a sysop |
| Global Renamer | Sysop on a content project for a minimum of six months | N/A | The candidate is not a sysop |
| Meta Permissions |
|
N/A | No global sysop or sysop on a content project |