Cross-wiki arbitration committee (2007 proposal)/Accepted cases/Yiddish Wikipedia

Cross-wiki arbitration committee (arbitration case)

This is a proposed process to resolve disputes such as the Yiddish Wikipedia case. It is not currently active.

This is an arbitration case concerning a dispute on the Yiddish Wikipedia. Do not edit this page unless you've read and understood the arbitration process. All content on this page may be edited by arbiters to maintain format and order.

Summary
Dates	[29 November 2024] Opened by Shmaltz and יודל (Yidel).
Users involved	Shmaltz (accounts, archives<permissions, spam blacklist>) (not confirmed) יודל (accounts, archives<permissions, spam blacklist>) ('Yidel', not confirmed)
Brief summary	Do not edit this box; the arbiters will do so.

Phase one: presentation

Summary of dispute

Describe the case below very briefly (in no more than 500 words). This should be a fair summary of the case, presenting no arguments and making no judgments as to the validity of any user's positions.

Yidel alleges that Shmaltz abuses administrator tools by constantly blocking users against Wikimedia policy and deleting articles in conflicts of interest. Yidel answers, that since shmaltz isn't active he must revert and sometimes hurt vandals feelings, and he uses each day other names not to be intimidated by the exposing of his privacy which was done numerous times. Edit here.

Shmaltz alleges that he has no choice but to block Yidel because he is disruptive by constantly edit warring with sock puppets and hurting other users' feelings.

Attempts at resolution

Briefly list previous attempts to reach agreement through the dispute resolution process.

• Invitations to neutral users:
  • 24 November 2006
  • 26 November 2006
  • User_talk:Danny#yidels_answer_on_runis_allegations
  • User_talk:Danny#why_you_did_it.3F
  • User_talk:Danny#please_remove_sysop-right_from_a_wandal
  • User_talk:Danny#Yiddish_wikipedia
• Request for comment (14 January—22 April 2007)

Agreement to arbitrate

All users must agree that any decision taken by the arbitration committee is binding and final. Although the committee may modify a decision if new evidence is provided, it has no obligation to do so. If you agree to abide by said decision, sign your name below by typing "* ~~~".

Edit here.