Jump to content

Community Wishlist/Wishes/Display definitions from Wikisource dictionaries

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Display definitions from Wikisource dictionaries Submitted

Edit wish Discuss this wish

Description

Wiktionaries aims to offer for each meanings only one definition but there are many ways to sentence a phrase to explain a meaning, many words - including local ones (i.e. an American-centered definition and an Indian-centered one for the same word) and very technical terms sometimes with more or less vulgarized explanations. A synthetic definition is a challenge, but more than one definition for each meanings should be a better strategy for neutrality.

Some alternative definitions from other open dictionaries could be presented to the audience in the reference section but there is no way of doing that now, despite the large amount of definition already accessible only and especially, in a Wikimedia project: Wikisource!

Wikisources contain a lot of dictionaries and we should use them to display more definitions. A dedicated transclusion of paragraphs from Wikisource in Wiktionaries would be a way, by hand/bot or with an automatic harvesting of entries with a specific tagging in the dictionaries hosted in Wikisources.

Maybe with an automatic tool or with manual linking?

They could come from several Wikisources, to be display in several Wiktionaries. It could be a new tab next to "Article" and "Talk", named "Dictionaries" with definitions for the same sequence of letters from dictionaries published in Wikisource.

For French, I can imagine at least a dozen of definitions from as much dictionaries. For under-described languages with at least one source in Wikisource, it could be an interesting way to compare the source and how it evolve after its inclusion in Wiktionary.

Assigned focus area

Unassigned.

Type of wish

Feature request

Wiktionary, Wikisource

Affected users

Readers wanting more than one definition, with different perspective. Wikisource editors to display and valorize their work. 

Phabricator tasks

T240191

Other details

  • Created: 09:56, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
  • Last updated: 11:12, 1 August 2024 (UTC)
  • Author: Noé (talk)